SMOKING GUN #58

THE 2005
EXTRADITION
TIMELINE

RECYCLED MUGSHOT PROVES FABRICATED IDENTITY

1

Photo

4

Different 2005 Dates

2

Different People

0

Ways This Is Possible

Billy Womack's May 11, 2004 Tampa booking photo (red shirt) was recycled and backdated to four different 2005 dates to create Francesco Longo's false identity — while Longo was documented in Canadian custody. Physical impossibility proves fabrication.

Document Date: February 1, 2026 | Status: HABEAS CORPUS EXHIBIT | Classification: SMOKING GUN

THE UNANSWERABLE QUESTION

"Your Honour, the same photograph — Billy Womack in a red shirt, taken May 11, 2004 in Tampa — appears in U.S. records attributed to Francesco Longo with four different 2005 dates. During all of 2005, Francesco Longo was documented in Canadian custody. How did he appear in Tampa for four separate bookings while imprisoned in Canada?"

The only answer: THE PHOTO WAS FABRICATED

¶1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

This document presents irrefutable proof of identity fabrication in the 2005 extradition of Francesco Giovanni Longo. The evidence establishes:

  • Recycled Mugshot: Billy Womack's May 2004 booking photo reused as "Francesco Longo" with multiple 2005 dates
  • Physical Impossibility: Longo documented in Canadian custody during all alleged 2005 Tampa appearances
  • DEA Attribution: Glenn Dutton attributed Womack's 2004 confession to Longo, initiating fraudulent warrant
  • Judicial Complicity: Justice Ducharme signed extradition in Windsor AND Toronto on same day — physical impossibility

¶2 THE RECYCLED MUGSHOT — VISUAL PROOF

THE ORIGINAL

BILLY WOMACK

Red Shirt Booking Photo

VERIFIED

Subject: Billy Womack

Date: May 11, 2004

Location: Tampa, Florida

Charge: 160 Ecstasy pills

Clothing: RED SHIRT

THE FABRICATION

"FRANCESCO LONGO"

Same Red Shirt Photo

FABRICATED

Attributed To: Francesco Longo

Dates Claimed:

  • • February 10, 2005
  • • March 28, 2005
  • • June 19, 2005
  • • August 22, 2005

Clothing: SAME RED SHIRT

THE IMPOSSIBILITY

During ALL of 2005, Francesco Longo was documented in Canadian custody.

He could NOT have appeared in Tampa for FOUR separate bookings while imprisoned in Canada.

CONCLUSION: The photo was RECYCLED and BACKDATED

¶3 THE COMPLETE TIMELINE (2004-2007)

MAY 11, 2004

Womack Arrest — THE SOURCE

Billy Womack arrested in Tampa with 160 Ecstasy pills. Red shirt mugshot taken. This photo will later be recycled.

VERIFIED: Tampa booking records

MAY 18-20, 2004

DEA Lab Discovery

DEA discovers MDMA lab at Womack's residence. Real crime scene, but Glenn Dutton will attribute Womack's confession to Longo.

DUTTON: False attribution begins

SUMMER 2005

Longo Arrested in Canada

Francesco Longo arrested on fraudulent U.S. warrant initiated by Dutton's false attribution. Begins 18-month detention.

Foreign charges backdated to "2005-02-22"

SEPTEMBER 6, 2005

Charges DROPPED — No Extradition Request

Charges dropped. No formal extradition request filed. Yet Longo remains detained and is later illegally transferred.

WHY transferred without request?

JANUARY 4, 2006

Bail Denied — Third Hearing

Longo remains silent in three bail hearings. All denied. 18-month fight continues despite dropped charges.

Fighting extradition without charges

APRIL 27, 2006

THE FORGERY — Two Cities, Same Day

Extradition papers signed by Justice Ducharme. Problem: signed in Windsor AND Toronto on same day. "Toronto" is scratched out.

  • Physical impossibility
  • False "consent" despite 18-month fight
  • No evidence admitted
FEBRUARY 14, 2007

U.S. Sentencing

Longo sentenced in U.S. based on fabricated identity and forged extradition.

2011

Release

Longo released after serving sentence. Fabricated conviction remains on record — preventing green card approval until USCIS finds NO matching criminal record.

¶4 THE FIVE IMPOSSIBILITIES

1

RECYCLED MUGSHOT

Same Womack photo (May 11, 2004) appears with four different 2005 dates attributed to Longo.

IMPOSSIBILITY: Cannot take same photo on four different dates

VIOLATION: s. 137 CCC Fabrication (14 years)

2

CONSENT vs. 18-MONTH FIGHT

April 27, 2006 document claims Longo "consented" to surrender. Documented record shows 18 months of active resistance.

IMPOSSIBILITY: Documentary contradiction — fight ≠ consent

VIOLATION: s. 131 CCC Perjury (14 years)

3

TWO-CITY SAME-DAY SIGNATURE

Justice Ducharme signed documents in Windsor AND Toronto on April 27, 2006. "Toronto" is visibly scratched out.

IMPOSSIBILITY: Physical impossibility — cannot be in two cities simultaneously

VIOLATION: s. 340 CCC Falsification (10 years)

4

NO EVIDENCE ADMITTED

Extradition report admits NO evidence was presented. Yet extradition was approved.

IMPOSSIBILITY: Legal impossibility — extradition requires evidentiary basis

VIOLATION: s. 139 CCC Obstruction (10 years)

5

TRANSFER WITHOUT REQUEST

Charges dropped September 6, 2005. No extradition request filed. Yet Longo was transferred to U.S.

IMPOSSIBILITY: Procedural impossibility — no request = no transfer authority

VIOLATION: s. 279 CCC Kidnapping (life imprisonment)

¶5 RESPONDENTS' IMPOSSIBLE DILEMMA

If Respondents Claim... Then They Admit...
"The photos are different people" Same red shirt, same pose — consciousness of guilt
"The dates are clerical errors" FOUR errors, all backdated — pattern proves intent
"Longo was in Tampa in 2005" Contradicted by Canadian custody records — perjury
"The consent was voluntary" 18-month fight documented — fabrication
"Ducharme traveled between cities" Why scratch out "Toronto"? — alteration proves fraud
"Transfer was lawful" No request filed after Sept 6, 2005 — kidnapping
Remain silent ADMISSION OF GUILT

NO ESCAPE PATH EXISTS

Every explanation leads to guilt. The timeline is irrefutable.

¶6 RELIEF SOUGHT

JUDICIAL RELIEF

  • Writ of habeas corpus per Dorsey v. Canada, 2025 SCC 38
  • Declaration: extradition void ab initio
  • Declaration: conviction void (fabricated identity)
  • Costs on substantial indemnity basis

CRIMINAL REFERRALS

  • RCMP: Glenn Dutton (s. 137, s. 465 CCC)
  • Canadian Judicial Council: Justice Ducharme
  • DOJ OIG: DEA Tampa Field Office
  • FBI: Cross-border identity fraud

THE UNANSWERABLE QUESTION (CLOSING)

"Your Honour, the same photograph — Billy Womack's May 2004 Tampa booking photo — appears attributed to Francesco Longo with four different 2005 dates. Longo was in Canadian custody during all of 2005. Justice Ducharme signed documents in two cities on the same day. Longo was transferred without an extradition request.

How does the Crown explain ANY of this?

The only answer that fits the evidence is FABRICATION from the very beginning."